Uncertainty and variability of extension rate, density and calcification rate of a hermatypic coral (Orbicella faveolata)

Skeleton growth variables of hermatypic corals, such as extension rate, density and calcification rate, are widely used to study coral response to environmental stressors, establish chronological age models and reconstruct the evolution of key climate variables. In this work, we addressed methodological aspects of the measurement of coral growth variables and the implications of their variability. A core of Orbicella faveolata was collected from the Puerto Morelos coral reef, in the Mexican Caribbean, and we measured and analysed 10 parallel transects of a core slab, covering 30 years. Density calibration was performed by measuring a high-quality and well-characterised wedge of Tridacna maxima, and the interval of interest was adjusted to the measured coral optical densities. The measurement uncertainties of extension rate, density and calcification rate were 0.011%, 1.1% and 1.6%, respectively. However, for density and calcification rate, overall variability was 29% and 33%, respectively, of which about half was attributed to intra-band growth variability. The intra-band variability of extension rate was only 0.68%, indicating the suitability of extension rate as a precise environmental proxy. These results likely differ by coral species, environments and experimental conditions, such as the exact location of the core within the colony and the method used to determine density. Uncertainties of coral growth variables should be carefully considered when reconstructing past environmental conditions.