Multi-Secular Trend of Drought Indices in Padua, Italy

The aim of this work is to investigate drought variability in Padua, northern Italy, over a nearly 300-year period, from 1725 to 2023. Two well-established and widely used indices are calculated, the standardized precipitation index (SPI) and the standardized precipitation evapotranspiration index (SPEI). They are compatible with a data series starting in the early instrumental period, as both can be estimated using only temperature and precipitation data. The Padua daily precipitation and temperature series from the early 18th century, which were recovered and homogenized with current observations, are used as datasets. The standard approach to estimate SPI and SPEI based on gamma and log-logistic probability distribution functions, respectively, is questioned, assessing the fitting performance of different distributions applied to monthly precipitation data. The best-performing distributions are identified for each index and accumulation period at annual and monthly scales, and their normality is evaluated. In general, they detect more extreme drought events than the standard functions. Moreover, the main statistical values of SPI are very similar, regardless of the approach type, as opposed to SPEI. The difference between SPI and SPEI time series calculated with the best-fit approach has increased since the mid-20th century, in particular in spring and summer, and can be related to ongoing global warming, which SPEI takes into account. The innovative trend analysis applied to SPEI12 indicates a general increasing trend in droughts, while for SPI12, it is significant only for severe events. Summer and fall are the most affected seasons. The critical drought intensity–duration–frequency curves provide an easily understandable relationship between the intensity, duration and frequency of the most severe droughts and allow for the calculation of return periods for the critical events of a certain duration. Moreover, the longest and most severe droughts over the 1725–2023 period are identified.